Google Slides – A Cool Tool for Everybody









As anybody that has been in a classroom or business conference room in the last 10 years knows, many spaces in which somebody is presenting information have some sort projection technology installed. It may be an interactive white board, LCD projector or even the growing use of interactive LED flatscreens. (Interesting summary here on one analyst’s view of what’s going to happen to interactive whiteboards in North America over the next few years.)


So instead of telling you what you already know about the importance and utility of some sort of presentation package, I’m going to instead do a bit of comparison between Google Slides and Microsoft PowerPoint. I’m going to leave Keynote and Prezi out of the comparison. I seldom dip into the Mac world, so I don’t know much about Apple’s presentation tool, Keynote, to help. The quick checks I found on Prezi seem to indicate it’s growing in use, but seems to lag the “big three” in use. Check out others comparisons here or here.  By no means are these the only choices out there.  Check this list out for other options. Even better, check out Saleh’s review of Visual.ly, Mike’s reviews of emaze and Haiku Deck, or Andrew’s review of Presetrain.

Cost Comparison Between Slides and PowerPoint

Traditional PowerPoint (PP) comes as either a purchased static download ($150 in the Office bundle) or as a purchased subscription that will keep your downloaded versions continually updated and provide 1TB of cloud storage ($70/year for one device and $100/year for up to 5 devices). PowerPoint Online (PPOL) is a free version of PP, albeit a stripped-down version.
Slides is free with a Google account. The Google account is also free, giving you a Gmail address, Google Calendar, 15GB of free cloud storage with Drive. Adding up to 1TB of cloud storage to your Google Drive is going to run the same $100/year as Microsoft Office 365 subscription.

Partridge and pear tree sold separately.

Lot of info there, but what do I think? I really wouldn’t give either an advantage. If you only make a couple presentations every once in a while and you already have a Google account, Slides is probably a good choice. If you use word processing, spreadsheets and presentation tools and can use the 1TB of cloud storage, you might want to consider traditional PP.

There are obvious privacy concerns that you must weigh when getting “free” stuff on the interweb, but those discussions are well beyond what I want to talk about.

Accessibility Comparison

Again, this will depend on what PowerPoint you consider. To create most documents, you’re probably going to be on a laptop, desktop or netbook. Mobiles like tablets and phones are probably best for reviewing and minor editing. With that said, Slides and PPOL both require access to the internet to either work with or just access the files. Downloaded versions of PP give you the freedom of creating and editing presentations anywhere, as long as you have your bigger device. PP gets the advantage for people on the move. Creating beautiful lesson presentations can’t be done in the park unless it is covered by Wi-Fi or you want to chew up some of your mobile data plan.
This is a personal choice. If you’re nearly always around Wi-Fi, it’s about a wash. If your favorite quiet place to work has spotty coverage, the downloaded PP might be better.

Ease of Use

Really, I don’t see much of a difference. Both apps look, feel and navigate nearly the same. It’s almost as if Google did that on purpose.

Features

Things separate a bit here.  PPOL has fewer features than Slides. Slides has fewer than PP. But how many do you really need?  PP has a built-in equation editor that works well with a stylus and touch screen. Slides has an available add-on that isn’t nearly as effective.  PP has a ton of icons, clip art shapes and the like built in. Slides is going to take you directly to the web for the search (almost as if Google has a vested interest in getting you to search). Dropping pictures from your device or cloud storage is about the same for either.  
Either has the capability of making many different presentations. PP is more feature rich, but it depends on why you’re using the tool.

Pretty Stuff

PP has a much large built in library of presentation templates and themes. And there is way more third-party material to augment what they have. Slides has some basics, they look good and you can vary them a bit. There is enough to keep things from always looking the same, but the selection is limited.

Integration

Slides is limited to YouTube for inserting video. It’s super duper easy, but a bit limiting. PP has the same easy interface to adding video as Slides, but you also can add video files in different formats (mpeg, mp4 and the like) directly from your device or cloud storage as well as linking to other video sites.
PP allows use of audio files. Neither Slides nor PPOL can deal with them. For slides you need to work around it by turning your audio into a video, linking the video and making it invisible when playing. Yuck. If you want to have audio during your presentation, stick with PP. If you don’t need it, Slide will still work for you.
Slides will allow you to convert a presentation into PP format and download it so it’s available for a PP user to open and edit. You can also import PP files into slides.

Collaboration


This is the area where Slides shows its mettle.  When shared, Slides allows multiple people can be working on different parts of the same files at the same time. This makes Slides a great tool for students and an educator might want to encourage their students to use it. Version control is a bit more complicated with PP; it’s design is more of a file owner with others contributing and suggesting. The owner has control over what revisions by contributors are accepted. I can see where teachers would have their students use Slides for projects but use PP for their stuff.

All in all, Slides is an effective presentation tool for teachers presenting content and for students creating content. It’s not flexible as PP, but it has the basics for putting together a presentation deck. If our getting fancy or using a lot of media, consider a different package









Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Kahoot! - Cool Tool or Strange Sound from an Owl?

Image
 It’s time for another Cool Tool review. This week I’m going to give my opinion of the Kahoot! app and hopefully give some insightful thoughts on how it can be used effectively in a classroom setting. (Wherever you see the Kahoot! or K! logos, I got them from the Kahoot! website. They make these available for download for anybody that wants to use them in an article.) Let’s get started! WHAT IS Kahoot! ? In a nutshell, Kahoot! is an application that allows teachers to create formative assessments and present them to the class in a game show format. Those are my words. Of course, the company that developed and distributes the app has fancier words. They call it “ a free game-based learning platform for teachers of awesome, classroom superheroes and all learners. ” I guess that’s the difference between an engineering background like mine and the marketing background of whoever wrote that copy.  PLEASE START WITH THE BASICS  HOW DO I GET IT?...
Read more

ITA Learning Project - My Journey from Youth to High School Coach – Post #5

Image
Ok, it’s been a while. Let me ‘splain. No, there is too much. Let me sum up. (If anybody reads this AND gets that, I’d love to hear it.) Last we left this thread, I was going into the first couple scrimmages for my team. I have been keeping notes all along on how this was going, but as I talked about way back in February , I have a tendency to worry about my writing so I was editing as I posted. So, while my last post on my coaching stuff was in early April and covered stuff that happened in early March, I still spent time rewriting the post instead of just putting it up. That worked well until both school and coaching got into full swing, so I got a bit behind in worddsmithing. Now I’m catching up. You’re going to see a few posts in the next few hours catching up about 6 weeks of stuff. Try to remember that time frame, please. First - I really wish I was better at remembering names. That is going to be such a big thing for me to work on as a teacher.   I don’t think I’l...
Read more

Cool Tool Review - fotor. Uh, NO!

Today I’m reviewing a photo editing tool, fotor, for my Cool Tool review. Unfortunately, this is the easiest review I’ve done. Right after we signed up for Cool Tools to review, I had a need for a photo editor. Thinking I’d be efficient, I figured I would try fotor out for my needs and for my review. To use the app on my laptop, I needed to download it. That’s when the trouble started. In addition to the photo editing app, I got a browser and a security app – neither which I knew was coming or agreed to. As far as I’m concerned, that’s dirty pool. The first thing I did when I noticed these extra apps was to uninstall fotor. After I did that, the app asked for feedback as to why I was giving it the boot.   I filled out the form and told them it was because I found these other programs and if it wasn’t because of them, they should let me know and I’d try again.   That was about 6 weeks ago. I haven’t heard yet so I’m going on the assumption that the extra programs on my devi...
Read more